3 Men & A Bagel

DaRel Samacicio 2 months ago

We ordered our breakfast bagels and an Oreo bagel with Oreo cream cheese. They never write down your order. When we got our order, there was no cream cheese on our bagel. We went up to get the cream cheese they had forgotten and they charge $2.69 for it and wouldn’t give us the bagel until we paid. Does this look like $3 worth of cream cheese?!?!? It was their mistake and they were not willing to fix it at no cost. Maybe they should write down the orders and practice better customer service.

Eric Herrera 5 months ago

For those who don't want to read a long review, I'm gonna start by saying DON'T EVER COME HERE. I had heard good things and saw good reviews on this place and how shocking it was when I went and actually had one of the worst breakfast experiences of my life. EVERYTHING on my breakfast sandwich was MICROWAVED. Cooking food this way really deteriorates the flavor. I get it can make things fast, but having lived in NY for 28 years, I've seen huge lines move faster than this with every sandwich being made on a griddle. The bagels are very very average. Anyone saying these are closest to NY bagels is actually just lying to you. Service was fine but I did notice the employees all chatting a lot more than prioritizing pushing orders out. 20 minutes if waiting to order and receive the food I got was not even close to worth my time. I reiterate, DO NOT COME HERE. Such a waste of time and money....

Laura Sayegh 5 months ago

Just don't go here. I wouldn't consider returning and would rather go to a diner, or another bagel shop. Im unable to justify paying for a breakfast sandwhich that has its contents microwaved, and I have more self respect for my food prep. The flavor was just okay and not very enjoyable. For what you're paying, just make it at home or go to a diner if you're considering ordering out. We got a breakfast sandwhich with sausage, egg and cheese. Hash browns tasted like cardboard and weren't toasted well or hot. They had a weird smell. Also got a veg. cream cheese on a bagel. Cream cheese felt not veggie heavy, more shredded carrots than a zing of onion etc. We did also get a coffee cake (which broke when they pulled it so we got crumbs more than cake, which was sad). Rasberry chocolate coffee was great. And the bagels were decent as a stand alone item. The workers were also nice. Still wouldn't come back.

Maryann DeStephano 5 months ago

Service here is consistently painfully slow. Every time I come in, it takes 30–45 minutes just to get a basic breakfast sandwich or bagel, even though it’s clearly simple food like microwaved eggs and prepped ingredients. What makes it worse is the lack of focus behind the counter. The staff are often more focused on chatting and socializing with each other than getting orders out. I’ve watched multiple times where they pause mid-task to continue conversations instead of finishing orders or helping the growing line of customers. On top of that, the customer service is not great. Most of the staff don’t seem friendly, rarely smile, and don’t make any effort to be personable, which makes the long wait feel even worse. The food itself is average at best, definitely not worth the wait times. It’s frustrating to stand there watching everything move so slowly while people are clearly waiting and trying to get on with their day. For how simple the menu is, the efficiency really needs serious improvement. Overall, it feels poorly managed and not set up to handle even a small rush. There are too many better breakfast spots nearby to justify coming back here.

Sal Sayed Edited 9 months ago

My visit to 3 Men & A Bagel in Pennsylvania was absolutely fantastic. Traveling from New York, a friend highly recommended this spot, and I am genuinely glad we stopped because it was completely worth it. We ordered an everything bagel with cream cheese, a jalapeño bagel with cream cheese, and a breakfast bagel sandwich with egg and melted cheese. Every item was excellent. The bagels had that perfect chew on the outside with a soft, warm inside. The everything bagel was generously seasoned, and the cream cheese was smooth and fresh. The jalapeño bagel had just the right amount of heat without overpowering the flavor. The breakfast sandwich was a standout. The egg was fluffy, the cheese was perfectly melted, and everything came together beautifully on the bagel. This is the kind of breakfast that feels satisfying without being heavy. We also grabbed hot black coffee, which paired perfectly with the bagels and was clean, strong, and well brewed. Despite there being a line out the door the entire time we were eating, the wait moved quickly and was absolutely worth it. The atmosphere was lively and upbeat, and the staff was friendly, welcoming, and efficient. Prices were very reason